WANISAN

Today I had a really interesting time (it is usually interesting, but today even more so) in my graduate course in American Literature and Culture.

We were discussing Ezra Pound’s poem “A River Merchant’s Wife – a Letter”.

This is not an original poem by Pound but actually a translation of a poem written hundreds of years ago by a Chinese poet named Li Po. Maybe you already knew that, but just in case, and because it is important to the rest of this discussion, I needed to bring that up.

There is of course some discussion among scholars, some heated discussions even, about the veracity, and accuracy of the translation. Pound said he was trying more for an image to image, ideal to ideal translation, but still he used some very literal translations in his version.

Keep in mind this was done in 1914 or so. Chinese was not a widely known language outside of China.

The places named were easy enough to verify and they do bring some additional understanding to the poem.

2 of my graduate students in this class are Chinese though, so we had a unique opportunity to discuss the original poem, which they were easily able to call up on iPads and compare Pound’s translation.

That was really interesting, but also interesting that one of the students knew the areas mentioned in the poem and had actually been there. He commented that the river mentioned is famous for being very dangerous as well.

They both were able to talk about the customs of early marriages and the way a wife would act which also shed some light on our discussions.

This class is usually interesting, but today, really interesting. Not the kind of class we usually have.

Here’s to next week and hoping it is still interesting as we move to one of my favorites, T.S. Eliot.

This week in Advanced Discussion we talked about a few more proverbs. One of the ones that seemed simple but brought a lot of talk was “ignorance is bliss”.

There are a lot of aspects to this proverb, but at its base it simply means “not knowing about some things is better and allows you to be happy” instead of stressing or worrying about something you may not be able to change.

While it surely isn’t good for you to be ignorant about a test you were supposed to be prepared for.

Students are not allowed to use a dictionary, so that is also part of the discussion.

“Ignorance” looks like a word many students know which is “ignore” or even “ignorant”. There is a connection, but it isn’t in the way some of the students thought. To be “ignorant” simply means “to not know about”. To be “stupid” means “to not be able to know”.

If someone asks you how to get to Nagoya station, it is okay to say you don’t know, but it is not okay to say you don’t understand.

Had this question at lunch the other day, and I thought the answer might be helpful for others.

We were talking about the difference between “look” and “see”. Sometimes there is confusion about when to use which one.

The simplest way to separate them is that “look” is an action and “see” is the result.

For example:

— Using “Look” and “See”

Look at the silly monkey using a computer.

Can you see that silly monkey using a computer?

Will you look in your room and see if your window is open?

I hope that makes it clear.